. Energy News .

For land conservation, formal and informal relationships influence success
by Staff Writers
Madison WI (SPX) Nov 02, 2011

The Malpai Borderlands.

During the past decade, voluntary contracts called conservation easements have become a popular method for conserving land. Embodied in an agreement between landowners and a government or non-governmental organization, these easements have differing goals, structures and financial arrangements.

As the area protected by easements has grown to 30 million acres, questions have multiplied. Are easements the most efficient way to conserve land and biodiversity? What easement structures are the most effective?

The answers are difficult to obtain, says Adena Rissman, an assistant professor in forest and wildlife ecology at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, who began exploring easements about 10 years ago.

"It's become clear that easements are not going to be easy to assess, compared to common park or wilderness area models, given the diverse goals, processes, and financing," Rissman says.

In a study published in late September in the journal Society and Natural Resources, Rissman and Nathan Sayre of the University of California compared two large easement projects dominated by grazing land: the Malpai Borderlands Group, straddling the Arizona-New Mexico border, and The Nature Conservancy's Lassen Foothills, in northern California.

Each project has more than 80,000 acres under easements, but they have differing origins, structures and conservation requirements, Rissman says. The borderlands project was intended to preserve habitat for the ranchers who had sold easements to a land trust that they control. The foothills easements are held by The Nature Conservancy, which helped fund Rissman's research and has explicit biodiversity conservation goals.

Although Rissman has long been interested in the efficacy of easements, her goal in this study was to explore the social relationships that helped or hindered progress, using interviews with landowners, conservation organizations, and scientists.

Social relationships, she says, affect the nature, terms and methods of the easement agreement, even when the easements have broadly similar goals in conserving grazing land.

"In comparing the two cases, we assumed that landowner goals and land trust goals were more closely aligned for Malpai than for Lassen, since in Malpai, landowners make up the majority of the land trust board," Rissman says.

"So we expected to find that the Malpai easements would contain fewer restrictions, that the restrictions would be behavior-based rather than performance-based, and that the monitoring would be less intensive, and this matches pretty closely what we found."

Also as expected, Rissman adds, Lassen contained a greater focus on direct conservation outcomes.

The surprising thing, Rissman says, was "the important role of informal, personal relationships. These were a stronger driver of conservation outcomes in Malpai, where ranchers were working together to raise funds for research and land management."

The tight social relationships at Malpai Borderlands existed long before the easements were written, Rissman says.

"Malpai is a unique organization created by a unique confluence of events, a longstanding effort to bring together the landowners to support their relations with governmental agencies that own a great deal of land in the region, and from which the ranchers lease large areas," Rissman says.

The Lassen project is more typical, with diverse landowners, and the easement process tended to strengthen social relationships that were looser to begin with, Rissman says.

"The existing social situation of each area helped determine how the land trust worked with landowners, and that affected the ability to meet conservation goals. Malpai was more concerned with preserving the grazing character of the land, and its major outcome was to limit building; the easements contained few restrictions on how ranchers managed their land."

Beyond restricting development, the Lassen easements prohibited the scraping and collection of volcanic rock from the grasslands, and required some landowners to install cattle-proof fences along streams to reduce erosion and water pollution. Lassen also had an enforceable requirement that landowners retain a certain amount of stubble through the winter to prevent erosion.

Particularly at Malpai, having outside advice and expertise was key to success, Rissman says. "Consultants and scientists participated; this was not a do-it-yourself project."

As far as can be told, both projects are meeting their goals, which reflects both a workable structure and effective management of social relationships, Rissman says.

"When we design and evaluate conservation programs, we need to pay close attention to these relationships, both formal and informal. Land managers need to account for more than just trees and birds. This is not just about resources, it's also about managing relationships among people."

Related Links
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Farming Today - Suppliers and Technology

Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
Buy Advertising Editorial Enquiries


. Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Stalemate over organic farming slows progress in effort to combat food insecurity in Central Africa
Kigali, Rwanda (SPX) Nov 02, 2011
The polarized debate over the use of organic and inorganic practices to boost farm yields is slowing action and widespread farmer adoption of approaches that could radically transform Africa's food security situation, according to a group of leading international scientists meeting in Kigali this week. "The ideological divide over approaches to farm production are a distraction from the ac ... read more

NASA Launches JPL-Built Earth Science Experiment

Halloween Weekend Snow Paints a Ghostly Picture in the U.S. Northeast

Landsat's TIRS Instrument Comes Out of First Round of Thermal Vacuum Testing

Small but agile Proba-1 reaches 10 years in orbit

Russia to launch four Glonass satellites in November

One Soyuz launcher, two Galileo satellites, three successes for Europe

Soyuz places Galileo satellites in orbit - mission control

GPS shoes for Alzheimer's patients to hit US

Forests not keeping pace with climate change

Niger capital's 'green lung' facing suffocation

Gibson Guitar boss backs tough timber trade rules

Savannas, forests in a battle of the biomes

Lincoln Increases Trucking Fleet to Expand Regional Biofuels Service

Animal Farm Powers Village by Alfagy

US Biofuel Production Increase: Fact or Wishful Thinking

Senegal's Wade regrets deaths after biofuels clash

Latin America set on solar energy growth

ONYX Announces Revolutionary "Plug-N-Play" All-in-One Solar Panel

SolarWorld Solar Panels Ready to Power Center Modeling World Advance in Sustainable Building

GE Unit and KGAL invest in 50MW Spanish CSP Plant

Mortenson Construction Builds Its Fifth Wind Facility In Illinois

Chinese Wind Market To Overtake Germany by 2018, Second Only to the UK

Huhne slams green energy 'naysayers'

Wind farm development can be powerful, as long as proper design is implemented

China coal mine blast kills 29: state media

Thirteen dead in China coal mine blast: report

Sundance says 'no reason' to doubt Hanlong deal

Mountaintop coal mining moves a step ahead

Weiwei gets more tax demands

US lawmaker asks China to show blind lawyer

China to give officials ethics training

Key US committee to take up China travel ban bill


The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2011 - Space Media Network. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement