Washington DC (SPX) May 06, 2011
A new study of foot-and-mouth disease shows that cattle afflicted with the virus are only infectious for a brief window of time-about half as long as previously thought. This finding suggests that the controversial control measures used to halt the disease's spread, such as killing large numbers of livestock, could be reduced.
The discovery is also changing the way that scientists think about infectious diseases in general.
"This study shows that what we thought we knew about foot-and-mouth disease is not entirely true," said Mark Woolhouse from the University of Edinburgh, a co-author of the study. "So, what we think we know about human influenza and other infectious pathogens might not be completely accurate either."
The report appears in the 6 May issue of the journal Science, which is published by AAAS, the international nonprofit science society.
Foot-and-mouth disease virus, or FMDV, is an RNA virus that infects cattle and other livestock animals, causing lesions on the tongue and feet, fever, and a runny nose. Each year, it's responsible for huge losses in the global livestock trade. Countries with endemic FMDV spend tremendous amounts of money vaccinating their cattle and farmers often kill off large numbers of livestock to control the disease once a clinical case has been confirmed.
In 2001, the United Kingdom experienced the biggest FMDV epidemic to strike a developed country in several decades. Hundreds of thousands of animals were killed and billions of British Pounds were lost before the disease was controlled.
Now, researchers have performed experiments with cattle to characterize the precise incubation and infectious periods of the disease-causing virus in live animals.
They found that even if the virus can be detected in a cow's blood sample-the traditional way of measuring infectiousness-it does not actually mean that the animal is infectious. In fact, a cow with FMDV is only infectious for 1.7 days, they say. After that, immune responses kick in and limit virus replication.
Bryan Charleston and colleagues from Pirbright Laboratory in the United Kingdom, along with Dr. Woolhouse, infected "source" cows with FMDV and studied how the virus was transmitted to other, uninfected cows.
Their experiment is different from previous studies that have only estimated transmission rates for groups of animals, rather than individuals.
"We have pinned down, very specifically, the relationship between when the animals are infectious with FMDV and when they show clinical signs of the infection," said Woolhouse.
"Normally, we only know if a person or animal is infected with disease when their clinical signs appear. But, what we didn't know before this is how those signs relate to infectiousness. In the case of FMDV, the clinical signs and infectiousness seem to occur around the same time."
In 28 attempts to infect healthy cows with FMDV (by placing them in close proximity to an infected cow for eight hours), the researchers only observed eight successful transmissions of the virus. In light of their results, Charleston and his colleagues suggest that cows with FMDV only become infectious for a brief period of time-approximately 0.5 days after clinical signs of the disease appear.
"We now know that there is a window where, if affected cattle are detected and removed from the herd promptly, there may be no need for pre-emptive culling in the immediate area of an infected farm," said Woolhouse. "We have an opportunity now to develop new test systems which can detect infected animals earlier and reduce the spread of the disease."
Their findings are consistent with a rarely tested theory that disease symptoms may be functionally linked to infectiousness.
"If you do things like measure virus in the blood, you're taking no account of the clinical state of the animal," said Woolhouse.
"People might imagine that the clinical signs of a virus-the symptoms, such as sneezing-have something to do with its transmission. But, while there has been a lot of thoughtful speculation on the topic, there haven't been many actual studies."
Charleston and his team are now calling for practical tools that could diagnose foot-and-mouth disease in the field before clinical signs appear.
According to the researchers, if FMDV could be detected in livestock just 24 hours before clinical signs appear, then farmers might have time to remove the infected animals before they transmit the virus.
"If the benefits of this research are going to be realized in the field, we are going to have to implement pre-clinical diagnostics," said Woolhouse.
"It's technically and logistically challenging, but our work shows that the potential benefits would be much greater than we've previously realized. So, at the very least, we should take a look at the possibilities for detecting FMDV early on."
The researchers also propose that similar studies could reveal much more about other animal (and human) pathogens in the future.
"We urgently need to evaluate other infections," said Woolhouse. "Until we do that, we can't evaluate how effective control measures like quarantining individuals, prophylaxis, anti-virals or the pre-emptive culling of livestock are going to be."
The funding for this research was born out of a special initiative, launched by the U.K. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council after the horrific 2001 outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease in that country. The researchers involved say that such direct experiments are vital to our understanding of public health.
"If you're going to make informed decisions about controlling infectious diseases, you need the right kinds of scientific evidence-and this study provides that, even if it wasn't easy or cheap to come by," concluded Woolhouse.
"People have used short-cuts before and we can end up with misleading information. This new research tells me that we can't afford to take those short-cuts. This is the kind of work we need to be doing to learn how to manage infectious diseases in the future."
The report by Charleston et al. titled, "Relationship Between Clinical Symptoms and Transmission of an Infectious Disease and the Implications for Control" appears in the 6 May issue of the journal Science. A related Perspective article by Graham Medley titled, "Diagnosing the Individual to Control the Epidemic" appears in the 11 May issue of Translational Medicine.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Farming Today - Suppliers and Technology
Seed Mixtures And Insurance Pest Management Are Future Norm In The Corn Belt
Chicago IL (SPX) May 06, 2011
As the use of biotechnology increases and more companies move forward with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's approval to begin full-scale commercialization of seed mixtures in transgenic insecticidal corn, many researchers believe pest monitoring will become even more difficult. "Seed mixtures may make insect resistance management (IRM) risky because of larval behavior and greater ... read more
Internet satellite images available to all|
Esri and DOI Introduce Landsat Data for the World
Satellites Reveal Tornado Tracks in Georgia, Mississippi and Alabama
NASA Mission Seeks to Uncover a Rainfall Mystery
'Green' GPS saves fuel, energy
Apple update fixes iPhone tracking "bugs"
Russia, Sweden to boost space cooperation
GPS Operational Control Segment Enters Service With USAF
Russian forest defenders say attacked near Moscow
Forest clearance threatens Sumatran tigers: WWF
Russian police arrest 25 activists in highway protest
First rainforests arose when plants solved plumbing problem
Formidable fungal force counters biofuel plant pathogens
Interjet and Airbus Conduct First Biofuel Flight in the Country
BioJet and Abundant Biofuels Agree to Merge
Food vs fuel: the debate is over
Measurement of hot electrons could have solar energy payoff
American Vision Brings New 'Light' to Solar Energy
Natcore Technology Successfully Uses LPD Process on Textured Solar Cells
Southwest Solar Announces New Collaboration at Research Park
Evolutionary lessons for wind farm efficiency
Global warming won't harm wind energy production, climate models predict
Study: Warming won't lessen wind energy
Mortenson Construction to Build its 100th Wind Project
Eight trapped in flooded China mine: state media
Wyoming to expand coal mining
China mine explosion kills 11, two missing
Wyoming coal leases to be auctioned
China archaeologists uncover more Great Wall ruins
Hong Kong comedian spreads cheer at Italy festival
Chinese writer barred from Australia trip: organisers
US says to raise rights in China talks
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|