by Staff Writers
Beijing, China (AFP) Aug 07, 2013
China's latest milk powder scare will do nothing to increase one of the world's lowest breastfeeding rates, experts say, in the face of misconceptions, economic pressures, and aggressive marketing that "brainwashes" mothers.
New Zealand dairy giant Fonterra was forced to issue recalls in countries ranging from China to Saudi Arabia following a scare over botulism, an infection that can lead to paralysis and death.
In China the scare recalled memories of a scandal over locally-produced tainted milk formula, which left six children dead and made more than 300,000 ill in 2008.
Ths scare was a key driver in a boom in imports that has seen the market for formula grow from a total $1 billion in 2002 to $9 billion this year, according to statistics from the United Nations' children's agency Unicef, and an expected $13 billion in 2015.
The demand for informal imports has at times seen supermarket shelves cleared around the world and retail purchase restrictions imposed from Britain to Australia.
Only 28 percent of Chinese mothers breastfeed for the first six months -- a figure which drops to 16 percent in urban areas.
The global average is about 40 percent, while more than 80 percent of mothers in the UK breastfeed.
Beijing was guilty of a "large marketing failure" to boost breastfeeding, said Robert Scherpbie, Unicef's chief of health and nutrition in China.
"The government is unable to market the benefits of breast milk at a very large scale, because there is this crowding-out by the other marketing from formula companies," he told AFP.
Manufacturers were "really smart with their marketing", he said.
Firms say that "they reinforce breast milk substitutes with all sorts of products that enhance learning, that makes your child smarter, and contains all types of immunogenic substances, whereas natural breast milk already has these substances", he added.
Scherpbie also said the growing Caesarean rates in China had also seen breastfeeding decrease. Just 50 percent of babies in China were delivered in hospitals in 2005, he said.
Hospital delivery is now almost universal but about half of those are Caesarean births, often with babies separated from their mothers soon after birth, making breastfeeding impossible.
Maternity leave could be extended from the current 98-day limit, Scherpbie added. But he said there was great pressure on mothers to return to work in China, where many families are supported by parents who work long hours.
Working mothers take to Internet message boards to air their frustrations over poor breastfeeding facilities in the workplace.
Yanhong Wheeler, a Beijing-based author of books on childcare and breastfeeding, said many Chinese mothers felt victimised because of a lack of basic knowledge on the quantity of breast milk a baby needs.
"The mother's family -- particularly the new grandparents and the mother-in-law -- blames the mother for starving the baby and for not having enough milk if there are any problems," she told AFP.
"And in the background of this, formula milk is everywhere. They are really aggressive about their products. They say they (products) are close to breast milk -- and that is a lie.
"I would say these companies are brainwashing, but not just mothers. Those that should be supportive are also being brainwashed."
Wheeler said babies are often cared for almost exclusively by the wider family in the first month after childbirth, when the mother is often bedridden.
Later, many Chinese babies remain in the care of grandparents when the mother returns to work.
Some formula milk providers approach mothers directly with their products and up to 52 percent of pregnant women had received a free trial, according to a survey by Beien, an Internet message board for new mothers.
"I received quite a lot of samples, mostly in small amounts and they kept coming until even after childbirth," one new mother in Beijing told AFP.
Formula companies in China -- including Abbott, Mead Johnson, Nestle, Wyeth and Yili -- were unavailable for comment.
Increasingly competitive formula companies have targeted markets in poorer countries in recent years. Campaigners have dogged Nestle for decades, claiming the company markets its products to women who would be better off breastfeeding.
Both Unicef and the World Health Organisation (WHO) recommend breastfeeding from birth to six months of age, and continued breastfeeding plus nutritious complementary foods thereafter, up to two years or beyond.
"Breastfeeding is a natural act, but also a learned behaviour which needs social and peer support," Marianna Trias, senior programme management officer for WHO in China, told AFP.
There were still "challenges... to overcome" in China, she added.
China fines baby formula firms $108 million for price-fixing: Xinhua
The firms fined were Mead Johnson and Abbott from the US, Dumex, a subsidiary of France's Danone, Friesland of the Netherlands, New Zealand giant Fonterra -- at the centre of a health scare this week -- and China's Biostime, Xinhua said, citing the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC).
In a corporate statement, Mead Johnson said it had been handed a penalty of 204 million yuan ($33 million).
Biostime said in a filing to the Hong Kong stock exchange that it had been given a 163 million yuan fine.
Fonterra, which has had to recall products in several countries this week over a botulism scare, was fined 4.5 million yuan, it said.
It cooperated fully with Chinese authorities and accepted their decision, it said.
"The investigation leaves us with a much clearer understanding of expectations around implementing pricing policies which is useful as we progress our future business plans," Fonterra's president for Greater China and India, Kelvin Wickham, said in a statement.
He added that Fonterra's fine was "in the lowest range" of the penalties handed out.
The NDRC, China's top economic planner, launched the investigation into high prices it said resulted from a monopoly-like situation, mostly targeting overseas firms. Several of them announced price cuts last month.
Xinhua said that three companies -- Wyeth, which is owned by Swiss giant Nestle, Japan's Meiji, and Chinese firm Beingmate -- had been exempted from punishment in the inquiry.
The NDRC said they provided important evidence and carried out active self-rectification, it added.
Farming Today - Suppliers and Technology
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2012 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement|