. Energy News .




POLITICAL ECONOMY
Walker's World: Why the IMF was wrong
by Martin Walker
Frankfurt, Germany (UPI) Oct 15, 2012

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only

In the five years since the financial crisis began, economic analysis has been dominated by the Keynesians who want more government stimulus spending to restart growth and the followers of Hayek and the Austrian school who insist on austerity by cutting public spending and paying down debt.

Now we should start paying attention to the French. For most of the crisis, the International Monetary Fund, the nearest we have to a system of global economic governance, has been in French hands. Its leaders have been two French finance ministers in succession, Dominique Strauss-Kahn (more famous now for extra-curricular activities) and Christine Lagarde, a lawyer by training.

The IMF chief economist since 2008, Olivier Blanchard, is probably more important. On leave from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology where he is a professor of economics (he previously taught at Harvard), he along with Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi is one of the three most powerful economists alive.

Blanchard has just revolutionized the academic debate about economic policy and the crisis. In the IMF's latest World Economic Outlook Blanchard and his team have come up with new research which convinces them that austerity is the wrong way to go.

Some of us saw this coming. Last December, Blanchard's blog referred to this ongoing research and its affect on the spreads on government bond yields. But he didn't spell out as clearly as he has now done the implications of the research.

To try and make a complex issue more simple, the question Blanchard's team addressed was the affect of cuts in government spending on gross domestic product growth. We know that cuts will reduce output, since there will be less money in the hands of the public to buy products and thus less incentive for manufacturers to make more. But it is hard to calculate how much the knock-on effects of the cuts bite into growth.

This is called the fiscal multiplier. Usually, we try to calculate this another way, by asking how much extra growth will a certain amount of extra government spending produce.

For the past decade and more, the IMF (and almost all government economists around the world) have assumed that the multiplier effect of spending cuts is 0.5; that is to say, cut public spending $100 billion and you cut growth $50 billion.

The new IMF research says this was wrong, and the multiplier effect is much greater -- somewhere between 0.9 and 1.7. That means that cuts of $100 billion means growth reduced $90 billion-$170 billion.

Wow! If that is right, the IMF is saying that the more you cut government spending the more your overall output will shrink -- and you will never get out of the hole. Your economic output just continues to decline, which is precisely what we have seen happening in Greece.

How could the IMF have been so wrong in the past? There are two explanations.

First, the previous calculations about the multiplier effect were made before the crisis when most of the world economy was doing fine. So when one country got into trouble and started to cut public spending, it could export its way out of trouble.

With the whole global economy faltering, that is no longer possible, and eurozone countries are no longer free to devalue their currencies which would make exports cheaper.

The second explanation is that for the past few years central banks have been artificially holding down interest rates to extraordinarily low levels, which distorts everything.

If the IMF is right, then the Keynesian school appears vindicated and the austerity school looks like a bunch of economic sado-masochists who should be locked away in the attic like so many crazy aunts. Government should start to use those low interest rates to borrow (and when governments can borrow for 30 years at 2 percent interest, that is like free money) and invest the money is job-creating infrastructure like repairs and maintenance on roads and bridges.

The best investment of all would probably be retro-fitting all buildings to Swedish standards for insulation, which would cut future energy costs dramatically and permanently.

A huge debate is under way among economists and financial analysts to double-check the IMF's research. At first sight, it is persuasive but there are weaknesses. Much of the analysis is Europe-based and gives a lot of weight to the experiences of Greece and Germany, which may not be typical, and no weight to some Baltic countries which succeeded with debt-reduction (but which were free to devalue).

The IMF is cautious about recommending changes in economic policy, saying only "if growth should fall significantly below current projections, countries with room for maneuver should smooth their planned adjustment over 2013 and beyond."

Translated, that means don't cut for the sake of cutting; remember the need for growth.

What they left out was an apology to the Greeks.

Related Links
The Economy




.
.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
...
Buy Advertising Editorial Enquiries




.

. Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle



POLITICAL ECONOMY
Fiscal policy should be 'growth friendly': IMF body
Tokyo (AFP) Oct 13, 2012
The world economy needs to balance austerity with growth if it is to recover fully from the global financial crisis, a key IMF committee said in Tokyo on Saturday. "Fiscal policy should be appropriately calibrated to be as growth-friendly as possible," the International Monetary and Financial Committee said in a communique. The statement came after days of back and forth between those -- ... read more


POLITICAL ECONOMY
GMES for Europe

Boeing Releases Updated Geospatial Data Management Tool

First images from e2v imaging sensors on SPOT 6 Earth observation satellite

New Commercial Imaging Spacecraft Progressing at Lockheed Martin as IKONOS Satellite Achieves 13 Years in Operations

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Testing of Galileo satellite navigation system can begin

Two more satellites for the Galileo system

Deployment of Europe's Galileo constellation continues

Soyuz orbits two Galileo satellites for Arianespace

POLITICAL ECONOMY
China to up reforestation

SciTechTalk: Amazon's 'razor blade' choice

Study finds nearly 50% of retail firewood infested with insects

Northern conifers youngest of the species

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Which Biofuels Hold the Most Promise for the Future

Palm Oil Massive Source of Carbon Dioxide

Super-microbes engineered to solve world environmental problems

Computational Model IDs Potential Pathways to Improve Plant Oil Production

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Interior Greenlights New Era for Solar Development on Public Lands in the Southwest

India Needs Concentrated Solar Power to Achieve Safer, More Reliable Energy Future

Motech Americas launches UL 1,000 Volt Certified Modules for PV Installations in North America

Germany raises electricity charge to finance renewables

POLITICAL ECONOMY
DNV KEMA awarded framework agreement for German wind project developer SoWiTec

Sandia Labs benchmark helps wind industry measure success

Bigger wind turbines make greener electricity

EU wind power capacity reaches 100GW

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Australian coal projects mega polluters?

Australian coal basin may be top 10 polluter: Greenpeace

Coal mining jobs slashed in Australia

China mine accident kills 10

POLITICAL ECONOMY
Former Chinese official sheds light on dark side of power

Chinese dissident author savages Beijing at German awards

Beverage tycoon tops Forbes' China rich list

China Nobel winner defends prize -- and Mao


Memory Foam Mattress Review

Newsletters :: SpaceDaily Express :: SpaceWar Express :: TerraDaily Express :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

.

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2012 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement